Clawhammer Question & Answer

As to the debate over the melodic style vs traditional styles, I don't feel the need to be critical of any player's approach. I've heard melodic players in a string band context who sound great. I've also heard more traditional players (round peak, etc.) who sound great playing solo or accompanying their voice. The greater the variety of approaches to the instrument that we explore, the further we'll take the art of clawhammer banjo.

Clawhammer banjo is not exclusively a "string band" instrument. Traditionally it was used in many different settings and contexts and should continue in the the spirit of that tradition.

Use it for accompanying your voice or a group "sing-in". Use it as a lead instrument in bluegrass, counrty or rock bands. Use it as a featured lead instrument that is more than capable of holding it's own against the guitar, fiddle or mandolin. And, of course, use it in a traditional string band.

Don't limit the instrument by insisting that there is a right or wrong way to approach clawhammer technique; their isn't... in fact, I'd stress the importance of getting comfortable with multiple styles.

Encourage all players, no matter what style they play, to continue to follow their particular muse when exploring the banjo. Melodic style banjo is very versatile, but I would feel it a great loss if it were the only style I played.

As I've said before, it's all good!










Thanks... Mike